Brian is an author of international
renown and public speaker. He is currently writing his book
Chinese Medicine: A Practical Guide to Optimal Healing. Brian
practices acupuncture and Chinese herbal medicine in sunny
San Diego, California.
|Can accupuncture help with pain of fibromyalgia? About
how many treatments can it take to see results and is it helped
along if you combine it with massage therapy and chiropractic
care? How do I find a reliable one in my area?
Thanks for the question, Debra.
There's just one 'c' in the spelling of acupuncture. I'm not sure
where this double-c misspelling came from.
Acupressure & Tui Na
The massage that acupressurists do may or may not be Chinese medicine.
If you ever go that route, check into how many years they were formally
trained in acupuncture/meridian theory. The standard "real"
massage of Chinese medicine is called Tui Na, which means "push
and grasp." More about massage below.
Acupuncture & Chinese Medicine
Acupuncture is just one therapy you can get from Chinese medicine
practitioners, who are generally called acupuncturists. Acupuncturist
isn't a great name, since most of us also are trained in Chinese
herbal medicine, cupping, moxibustion, food selection, lifestyle
advice, etc. All of these therapies are based on the Chinese medical
Accurate Fibromyalgia (FM) Diagnosis
I want to make sure you've had a doctor spend enough time with
you to get you a proper FM diagnosis according to the standardized
criteria. Too many doctors just toss this term around without using
the criteria (which is unethical - imagine the negative emotional
impact - worry, fear, etc. that it has on patients!) Who
knows how many people think they have it, when they really have
something else entirely? And so long as they try to treat the wrong
thing, they'll use the wrong remedies, and whatever condition or
problem you do have will remain untreated. This is one reason why
I advocate seeing health professionals instead of self-care; misdiagnosis
leads to the wrong treatment and perhaps even further harm. Read
about the criteria for the FM diagnosis here,
and make sure they've been applied to your case. If they haven't,
get a second opinion!
The Chinese Medicine Treatment of Fibromyalgia
I will defer to the experience of my wife, Dr. Lynda Harvey-Carter,
since she has helped hundreds of FM/CFS sufferers get better. That
information is covered in this
The upshot is that 80% of patients experienced marked improvement
(decreased chronic fatigue and fibromyalgia symptoms), and 50% said
they had been completely cured. This is not an instantaneous process,
but most of the patients had experience significant improvement
within 3-4 months.
Affordable Fibromyalgia Care
I know all of this care costs money. Most patients want to do whatever's
going to be most effective at the least cost. I can't see any other
reason to worry about how many times you'd have to visit an acupuncturist,
so I'm going to say more about FM treatment in terms of cost-effectiveness.
Chiropractic for Fibromyalgia?
To be quite candid, for the FM sufferer, I'm not convinced that
chiropractic is the best way to spend your money. Many FM/CFS sufferers
experience greater pain and symptoms after an adjustment. This may
be a neccesary part of healing, but if there's not an x-ray confirmed
spinal issue to be addressed, I wouldn't do it. Though many of them
are good and honest, and though I am open-minded about their role
in the treatment of non-spinal issues, chiropractors are well-known
for their aggressive marketing techniques, so be careful. To be
clear: chiropractic may help you. This isn't my area of expertise.
Massage for Fibromyalgia?
Massage can be nice, but I'm not sure it's the best for FM either.
Deep techniques can make FM patients feel worse. The light, soothing,
circulatory/Swedish style can relieve stress, and lightening the
load on your sympathetic nervous system and adrenals, but there
are less expensive relaxation methods. I think the best test is:
how long does your relief last? If it's just a few hours, how much
would it cost to maintain that benefit 24 hours a day, 7 days a
Acupuncture Treatment for Pain
On the other hand, acupuncture has proven its ability to relieve
both new and old pain. It is the safest pain relief technique. It
is the only pain reliever I know of that can wipe out chronic pain.
It works via the nervous and immune systems, which are two major
systems that FM/CFS affects. It releases natural opioids that can
relieve pain for 1-3 hours (endorphins) and 1-3 days (enkephalins).
It also, via some other route, normalizes the way the brain interprets
sensations, and erases the grooved in patterns of chronic pain.
Chinese herbs, like acupuncture, can work systemically, and/or
they can be targeted. Chinese medicine discovers your particular
constitution and patterns of imbalance, and seeks to balance them,
thus giving the body the strength to restore normalcy.
Working With Medical Professionals
Find health practitioners who are qualified AND that you can trust,
because they have the training and experience to make accurate diagnoses,
choose appropriate remedies, and make the best plan for your healing.
Once you've found good practitioners, follow their advice. Trying
to save money on alternative health care may tempt you to ignore
your practitioner's treatment plan and see them less often than
they suggest. Or, you may try to avoid professionals and get your
information from magazines (whose number one goal is to sell advertising
- thus, they do not go into complex medical issues or therapies
in the kind of depth needed for safe and accurate usage of natural
medicines, nor do they print articles that compete with or contradict
their advertisers products).
The Chinese Medicine Fibromyalgia Expert
If there is a FM/CFS expert in Chinese medicine, it's Lynda Harvey-Carter.
I haven't heard of anyone else who's had as much success. To follow
her program, you'll need to go to a Chinese medicine practitioner
for a good 12-16 weekly visits, get herbs and take them religiously,
do some counseling on any emotional issues you have (pre-FM, or
just dealing with FM),change your diet, take certain nutrients,
and get involved in spiritual growth that requires growth of character,
trust, surrender, hope, and faith. The patients who were most willing
to make the most changes in their lives were most likely to recover
completely from their FM.
The other insight that Lynda had about recovery from FM is that
the sooner you catch it and treat it, the better recovery you can
have. It's not unheard of for people newly diagnosed with it to
get serious about treating it and completely recover. I mean it
goes away. For good.
But if you only go halfway, or you wait too long to do something
about it, you may be ensuring that you have to put up with this
pain for the rest of your life.
How to Find a Good CM Practitioner in Your Area
Use my website's acupuncturist-finding resource (see below). Most
people end up at the National database. Remember, when you search
your city or state, that although some practitioners have not taken
the national herbs test, they may still be trained in, good at,
and legally allowed to prescribe Chinese herbs. Many states only
look at the acupuncture test, and include Chinese herbs in the acupuncturist's
scope of practice.
A common question patients ask is "how many people have you
treated with my disease?" That's a sensible question, but perhaps
not always the best one. Most CM practitioners treat a little bit
of everything. Some try to specialize, or end up get referrals for
a particular disease, but most are general practitioners. I'd say
this is possible because, although CM is quite complex, it is not
nearly as complex as most western medicine (WM) specialties. Also,
WM specialization has become the norm, and because there are 800,000
of them in the U.S., the may have to specialize! However, there
are only about 15,000 acupuncturists here, so we need not, and perhaps
cannot specialize yet. Fortunately, we learn enough in school to
be good general practitioners, and there are more and more reference
books. Many experienced practitioners have shared their successes
with the rest of us, and translators are constantly offering English-speaking
acupuncturists new Chinese experience or research on many topics.
6 Steps to Getting the Best CM Practitioner for You
1. Go to The Pulse of Oriental Medicine's Acupuncturist
Finding Resource, and look for your town. If you don't see
it, click on the "general databases" link, then choose
"National Certification Committee for Acupuncture and Oriental
Medicine," then search by your city. If that doesn't work,
try state-wide, and choose the nearest ones.
Pick 3 or 4 names, and give them a call. Ask if they provide a "short,
free consult." If they offer to do this in person, take
them up on it, because you'll get a much better sense of them that
way. However, many will assume you mean a free "phone consult."
Make sure you get to talk to the actual acupuncturist. Most of them
will talk to you for as much as 15 minutes. If only one of your
group does this, I'd say that's a strong testimony to their sensitivity
and marketing savvy, unless they are so successful that they don't
have time. Try to get even 5 minutes on the phone with them. While
you're listening, look for intelligence, sensitivity, compassion,
ability to listen and adapt, and ability to communicate clearly.
Ask them about their education (where, when, how many years).
Find out if they got a degree in Chinese medicine, or - if they
are a medical acupuncturist (chiropractor, MD, DO, or naturopath)
- if they just took a weekend course, or even worse, a video course.
You want someone who either got a 3 or 4 year Master's degree, and
had to take a licensure exam required by the state, or a medical
acupuncturist who devotes all or most of their practice time to
Ask them about their experience treating your condition (see
above caveat). This will tell you how confident they are. A good
practitioner with little experience may still know how to do as
much for you as possible, especially if they keep up on the literature!
But experience does have value.
5. Cost & Payment:
Find out how much they charge for initial and follow-up visits,
if they have payment arrangements, and if they will bill your insurance
(if your insurance covers it). Their charge will tell you more
about their confidence level, and to some degree this is a measure
of competence, although I have heard of bad care given by practitioners
who nonetheless charged more than they deserved. Likewise, some
very good and confident practitioners may not charge exorbitantly
for their own philosophical reasons. The reasonable range is from
$80-300 for an initial 2 hour visit, including acupuncture, and
from $50-150 for follow up visits.
6. Compare & Decide:
Compare the results of your phone consults, not just in numbers
and data, but on your "gut" feeling. It's important
to have a good rapport with your practitioner to facilitate essential
communication, relaxation, and trust. People are sometimes different
on the phone, so I wouldn't make this your determining criteria,
but it may help you decide if the other factors are more or less
Ok, that's probably more info than you expected! Let me know if
you have any further questions.